As the midterm elections approach, speculation is rife about who might become the fall guy for Donald Trump’s administration. Among the names being tossed around, one stands out: Pete Hegseth, the Secretary of Defense, often derisively referred to as the 'Secretary of War.' With a history of controversial decisions, strained relationships with Congress and the military, and questionable financial dealings, Hegseth seems tailor-made for the role of scapegoat.
The Need for a Fall Guy
Trump has a well-documented history of shifting blame onto others when things go awry. After the 2018 midterms, Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke were among those who found themselves out of favor. This time, Hegseth appears to be in the crosshairs, particularly as Trump seeks to distance himself from the unpopular Iran war, which has driven up oil prices and alienated voters.
Hegseth’s Troubled Tenure
Hegseth’s time as Secretary of Defense has been marked by controversy. A survey by the veterans’ group Common Defense Civic Engagement found that 53% of active-duty service members want him gone, with 45% saying his policies have made them consider leaving the military sooner. Additionally, Hegseth has clashed with military leadership, pushing out roughly two dozen generals and admirals, a move described as 'dangerous and destabilizing' by critics.
Congress has also taken issue with Hegseth. Representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky introduced articles of impeachment against him, a rare move by a fellow Republican. The resolution was nearly voted on before House Speaker Mike Johnson called a recess to kill it. Massie has vowed to reintroduce the resolution after the midterms, suggesting Hegseth’s position is increasingly untenable.
Financial Scandals and Personal Controversies
Hegseth’s financial dealings have raised eyebrows. According to the Financial Times, he attempted to make a multimillion-dollar investment in defense stocks before the Iran war, a move that could be seen as insider trading. BlackRock flagged the communication internally, creating a paper trail that could be subpoenaed. This, coupled with his seemingly chaotic personal finances—including a $19,000-per-month mortgage on a $3.2 million house he can’t afford—makes him a prime target for investigation.
There’s also the matter of Hegseth’s alleged alcohol problem, which he has denied. His chief of staff, Rick Buria, reportedly spread rumors about Hegseth’s drinking, yet mysteriously retained his position. This has led to speculation about Hegseth’s ability to lead effectively.
The Political Calculus
Trump may see Hegseth as a convenient scapegoat for the Iran war’s failures. By firing him, Trump could appease both Congress and the military while shifting blame for the war’s unpopularity. Additionally, removing Hegseth could pave the way for an investigation into his financial dealings, which could further distance Trump from the scandal.
However, some argue that Hegseth is too valuable to Trump as a loyalist. As one commenter noted, 'The Project 2025 cabal needs a guy like Hegseth...to be willing to do the unconstitutional and war crimey stuff they plan to do.' Others suggest that Trump might 'demote' Hegseth to a Senate seat in Tennessee, a move that could save face while avoiding a messy impeachment.
The Military’s Perspective
The military’s disdain for Hegseth is palpable. One commenter remarked, 'Hegseth has done more damage to the US military than anyone else in US history.' His push to remove senior leaders who disagree with him has created a culture of fear and loyalty, but it has also alienated many within the ranks. As another commenter put it, 'A lot of these people care far more about the military than about politicking, and it is unquestionable the damage Don and Pete have done to the military's reputation and preparedness.'
The Road Ahead
Whether Hegseth becomes the fall guy remains to be seen. Trump’s decision will likely depend on the midterm results and the political calculus of the moment. If Democrats regain control of Congress, Hegseth’s position could become even more precarious, as they would have the power to pursue investigations and impeachment proceedings.
In the words of one observer, 'Hegseth is just the lowest-hanging fruit.' But in the world of Trump’s administration, even the lowest-hanging fruit can be hard to pluck. As the midterms draw near, all eyes will be on Hegseth to see if he becomes the latest casualty in Trump’s game of political survival.